The Best Opinions On Kelly Slater's Wave Pool Yet Are In Part 2 of SW's Fireside Chat

7 Feb 2018 3 Share

Is this the future of competition surfing? World Title contender Courtney Conlogue at the experimental Future Classic WSL event in 2017. Photo: WSL/Morris

Is this the future of competition surfing? World Title contender Courtney Conlogue at the experimental Future Classic WSL event in 2017. Photo: WSL/Morris

“As a surf experience it was dissatisfying…”

Surfing World Magazine recently hosted the first of their fireside chats series, taking on the Slater Wave Pool with the talking heads and opinions of surf writing legend Nick Carroll, Surfing World Editor Vaughan Blakey, two time World Champ Tom Carroll, Stab/Surf Europe/Beach Grit founder Derek Rielly, former World No.1 and one-time wave pool competitor Rob Bain, and wave pool creator/surfing futurist Greg Webber talking about it all on some couches. It was great.

But little did we know that all the most interesting thoughts and opinions around the pool would drop in part II of the same conversation! Just like The Godfather, no.2 is where it's at.

You should head on over to the Surfing World website and watch it right now.

Where Part I went into great detail about what the experience of surfing the pool is actually like, the second half of the discussion bounces wildly about what this all means for surfing

“As a surf experience it was dissatisfying,” says Nick Carroll.

Greg Webber counters that with the idea that WSL surfers and people like Nick Carroll – elite surfers – are the stage for the pool, but the reality is the market for wave pools is a different type of surfer entirely (worse surfers, of which there are many more of).

Derek Rielly posits that in 50 years there will be empty lakes and wave pools all over the world, like roller skating rinks built in the disco-70s.

“I find it really hard not to be close minded on this,” says Rob Bain, adding, "I kind of don’t want to know about it.” He then explains with the wit we love him for just why that is.

“The best pool hasn’t been built yet,” says Greg Webber.

“Don’t you think the best analogy is sex workers?” asks Derek Rielly.

Nick Caroll tells us of his existential crisis in the pool, and his saving revelation: “I was tortured by that pool … I was extremely angry that the whole thing was being kept at arms length from the surfing communities of the world ... I immediately realised that the wave pool is nothing to be afraid of. They don’t hold a candle to the ocean.”

And Surfing World Ed, Vaughan Blakey, had a typically Vaughan Blakey simple, yet clear in its pure love of surfing, take on what this all means for surfing:

“At the end of the day, if there’s a wave, and you surf, it doesn’t matter if it’s in the Basque country, or Lemoore, it’s fun,” he said.

Seriously, its good viewing. Crack a beer or pour yourself a cup of tea or perhaps eat a sandwich, and sit down to give it a watch over on Surfing World dot com dot ay younow.

Tags: (create Alert from these tags)

blog comments powered by Disqus
Features
Asher Pacey Is Smooth Surfing Personified, Noa and Ozzie Go Wild in NZ, and Novelty River Waves!

Asher Pacey Is Smooth Surfing Personified, Noa and Ozzie Go Wild in NZ, and Novelty River Waves!

This Week In Surfing: Ten Things From Surfing & The Internet On The Week That Was January 18, 2019

18 Jan 2019
Pumping Off The Wall D'Bah This Week

Pumping Off The Wall D'Bah This Week

Featuring Parko, Asher Pacey, Sheldon Simkus, Mitch Parkinson, Bear Cummings, Jag Bartholomew, Durbo, Wade Carmichael, Nic Vasicek and many more.

18 Jan 2019
Weekend Surf Forecast 18 - 20 January, 2019

Weekend Surf Forecast 18 - 20 January, 2019

Another salubrious summer weekend of waves is fast approaching.

1 17 Jan 2019
Recent

Watch: Meet Young Aron Cox, South Coast Charger

The 18-year-old met his fair share of all-time swells last year

2 15 Jan 2019
"Say No To Tar" Rally Planned For Crescent Head

"Say No To Tar" Rally Planned For Crescent Head

10 10 Jan 2019
Watch: Ry Craike's Incredible Barrel-Fest Is Must See Surf Viewing

Watch: Ry Craike's Incredible Barrel-Fest Is Must See Surf Viewing

4 7 Jan 2019
Upload Your Photos to Win $2400 Worth of Ocean & Earth Goodies!

Upload Your Photos to Win $2400 Worth of Ocean & Earth Goodies!

2 1 Jan 2019
Watch: Mick Fanning and Jay Davies Shred Fun n Throaty West Aus Roll-Ins

Watch: Mick Fanning and Jay Davies Shred Fun n Throaty West Aus Roll-Ins

1 1 Jan 2019
Latest News

Watch: Meet Young Aron Cox, South Coast Charger

The 18-year-old met his fair share of all-time swells last year

"Say No To Tar" Rally Planned For Crescent Head

Residents and Kempsey Shire Council set to clash over the contentious sealing of Plomer Road

Watch: Ry Craike's Incredible Barrel-Fest Is Must See Surf Viewing

It's very early, but let's put this as the placeholder for top clip of 2019 for the time being.

Upload Your Photos to Win $2400 Worth of Ocean & Earth Goodies!

The Summer Waves Photo Competition is back

Popular This Week

Watch: The Japanese Armageddon Swell of Swells

Things got pretty hectic when Typhoon Lan pushed a serious amount of swell in Japan's direction.

Brad Norris Is a Tube King, Ry Craike's Best Clip Ever, and the Burleigh Single Fin Comp Rules

This Week In Surfing: Ten Things From Surfing & The Internet On The Week That Was January 11, 2019

Shaun Harrington's Mental D'Bah Drainer

Wave of the Week: Six seconds of mental D'bah funnel

Upload Your Photos to Win $2400 Worth of Ocean & Earth Goodies!

The Summer Waves Photo Competition is back

Go to Top