Nick Carroll On: The Martha's Dilemma

12 Jan 2018 2 Share

Nick Carroll

Senior Writer

Photo courtesy of Surfrider and SeanDavey.com

Photo courtesy of Surfrider and SeanDavey.com

We have to save Martha Lavinia Beach!

Suport is building to save one of Australia's best (though kind of secret) beachbreaks under threat from a proposed large salmon farm.

Barton Lynch is on board. Last week BL released a statement in support of the fight to protect the beach, calling it “one of the best beachies I have ever surfed”. He joins others, including Tom Carroll, Julian Wilson and the fantastic photographer Sean Davey, in sounding the alarm.

What’s amazing is that until very recently, I bet the vast majority of surfers in Australia didn’t have a clue about Martha Lavinia Beach.

You’ve seen it, for sure. Pros and photographers have been going to Martha’s for at least 25 years. Shots have been piled in to surf mags and ads. Experimental surf contests have been held there. The free-form collaborative movie Musica Surfica  was shot there.

But the whole time, it’s been kept in the box marked “Secret Spot”. So secret that only now, when it’s under serious environmental threat, is it being publicly named and located.

Martha Lavinia, on the north-east coast of King Island, is a surfing freak of nature. Facing directly away from one of the world’s greatest swell machines, it nonetheless turns those swells maybe a dozen times a year into magic.

A big Southern Ocean swell will do a double-wrap around the island and approach Martha’s in crossed-up fashion, creating flawless wedges up and down a starkly beautiful line of beach, in what one long term King Island visitor calls “the clearest water I’ve ever seen”. And sure enough, the prevailing wind is offshore.

It’s not easy to score, even if you’re one of the hundred or so surfers on the island. If you’re flying in from the mainland, either on one of the twice weekly King Island commuter flights or a charter of some kind, it’s even harder. Your timing has to be spot on.

All this has helped keep Martha Lavinia in the secret box. And it might have stayed there for another 25 years, had Tassall not raised its head.

Tassall is Australia’s biggest salmon farmer. You may know of the company thanks to a recent ABC Four Corners report which raised big questions about its farming practices off Tasmania’s east coast, where neighbouring fish farmers have accused Tassall of overstocking. Further west, in Macquarie Harbour, mass die-offs of Tassall-farmed fish thanks to water oxygen depletion have occurred, and the company only recently stepped back from a plan to dump tonnes of waste from the farm directly back into the waterway.

Now it wants to explore setting a farm for around a million salmon off the beach directly south of Martha’s. And it's not just visiting surfers who are aghast.

“I’m going to fight this all the way,” Charlie Stubbs told Coastalwatch. Charlie, a diver and fisherman who has taught in King Island schools all his working life, says the farm will lethally imperil King Island’s brand as a source of clean, high end food product. “King Island is dependent on its clean brand,” he says. “But Tassall wants to double production, and King Island offers them better tidal wash-through.”

One thing’s for sure, it’s impossible to see how Martha’s could survive, intact, the equivalent of a giant waterborne cage-egg chicken farm to its immediate south. Photographer/filmmaker Shane Peel says it’s “fragile … the sand itself is fragile. It’s PRISTINE.”

But hang on. Saving this spot means telling all the rest of us about it.

Isn’t this a big no-no? Or is the threat so great it overwhelms the secrecy?

The King Island locals are renowned for welcoming surf visitors, but if that turned from a trickle of in-the-know pros and filmers into a minor flood of hopefuls, how long would that last?

“Even if it’s exposed, I can’t see it becoming crowded,” says Peel. “It’s inconsistent, a rare natural event. It’s hard to get to.”

Mick Sowry, who directed Musica Surfica, says he thinks the spot’s been more of an open secret than an actual one. “A lot of the core surfers in Victoria would know about it,” he reckons. “You could argue that it might bring (surf) tourism, but that may not be a bad thing.” Especially if it can provide some economic argument against a fish farm.

Charlie Stubbs say he understands the tension around surf secrecy. “It’s a point,” he says.

But he makes a pretty blunt point in return: “I guess it’s either share it with the world, or surf in fish shit.”

Photo courtesy of Surfrider and seandavey.com

Photo courtesy of Surfrider and seandavey.com

If you’d like to help rescue King Island and Martha’s from this shitty salmony fate, visit the Facebook page or sign the petition here.

Tags: topnews , (create Alert from these tags)

blog comments powered by Disqus
More From Nick Carroll
Nick Carroll: Christmas and New Year Wishes for the Surfing World

Nick Carroll: Christmas and New Year Wishes for the Surfing World

2018 has waxed a lotta boards, and it’s down to its last, sandy little scrap, so here’s CW’s best wishes from a crazy cluttered year

8 30 Dec 2018
"They Thought We Were Crazy"

"They Thought We Were Crazy"

RIP Scott Dillon, first of the wild boys.

12 Dec 2018
NICK CARROLL: The Next RSL

NICK CARROLL: The Next RSL

Sign of the times! Boardriders’ clubs have... clubs!

5 10 Dec 2018
Recent

Watch: Meet Young Aron Cox, South Coast Charger

The 18-year-old met his fair share of all-time swells last year

2 15 Jan 2019
"Say No To Tar" Rally Planned For Crescent Head

"Say No To Tar" Rally Planned For Crescent Head

10 10 Jan 2019
Watch: Ry Craike's Incredible Barrel-Fest Is Must See Surf Viewing

Watch: Ry Craike's Incredible Barrel-Fest Is Must See Surf Viewing

4 7 Jan 2019
Upload Your Photos to Win $2400 Worth of Ocean & Earth Goodies!

Upload Your Photos to Win $2400 Worth of Ocean & Earth Goodies!

1 1 Jan 2019
Watch: Mick Fanning and Jay Davies Shred Fun n Throaty West Aus Roll-Ins

Watch: Mick Fanning and Jay Davies Shred Fun n Throaty West Aus Roll-Ins

1 1 Jan 2019
Latest News

Watch: Meet Young Aron Cox, South Coast Charger

The 18-year-old met his fair share of all-time swells last year

"Say No To Tar" Rally Planned For Crescent Head

Residents and Kempsey Shire Council set to clash over the contentious sealing of Plomer Road

Watch: Ry Craike's Incredible Barrel-Fest Is Must See Surf Viewing

It's very early, but let's put this as the placeholder for top clip of 2019 for the time being.

Upload Your Photos to Win $2400 Worth of Ocean & Earth Goodies!

The Summer Waves Photo Competition is back

Popular This Week

Watch: The Japanese Armageddon Swell of Swells

Things got pretty hectic when Typhoon Lan pushed a serious amount of swell in Japan's direction.

Brad Norris Is a Tube King, Ry Craike's Best Clip Ever, and the Burleigh Single Fin Comp Rules

This Week In Surfing: Ten Things From Surfing & The Internet On The Week That Was January 11, 2019

Watch: The Gold Coast This Week With An All-Star Cast

Mick Fanning, Owen Wright, Joel Parkinson and crew in and around the Queensland/New South Wales border this week.

"Say No To Tar" Rally Planned For Crescent Head

Residents and Kempsey Shire Council set to clash over the contentious sealing of Plomer Road

Go to Top